A newly compiled list of foods and drinks commonly consumed in the United States hints at why many adults unknowingly overdo it on saturated fat and added sugar in their daily diet, a new study suggests. Beyond the biggest sources of each dietary category – cheese for saturated fat and soft drinks for added sugar – the study identifies a longer list of popular sources that helps explain why it’s so hard to limit fat and sugar to the recommended 10% of daily calories. With that overconsumption of unexpected sources like chicken and ketchup, for example, comes a risk for a variety of ailments, such as cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and cancer.
The analysis of data on over 35,000 U.S. adults is part of a project aimed at developing a research tool that can streamline assessment of these dietary downsides. But the work also may open consumers’ eyes to the unexpected sources of fat and sugar that add up over the course of a day – and perhaps convince shoppers to read labels to see where these hidden sources are, researchers say.
“Chicken breast is promoted as a lower saturated fat food, but it still has a little bit of saturated fat. But it is helpful to know how foods with smaller amounts also slowly add saturated fat in a stealthy way into the diet,” said first author Christopher Taylor, professor and director of medical dietetics in the School of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences at The Ohio State University.
“Being able to meet less than 10% is to identify the big contributors, but also to be able to see where saturated fat and added sugar may still exist in other food choices. It doesn’t make them poor choices – it’s about being aware of how the morning latte may be contributing.”
And then there’s the abundance of added sugar, which raises a public health policy concern, said lead author Susan Schembre, associate professor of oncology at Georgetown University’s Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center.
“It’s everywhere. It’s in so many unexpected foods, and often in surprising amounts,” she said.
The study was published recently in the journal Nutrients. Researchers analyzed data from 36,378 U.S. adults aged 19 and older who had participated from 2005 to 2018 in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. The survey collects 24-hour dietary recalls from each participant – detailing not just what, but when, all food and drinks were consumed over the previous two days.
Overall, the top sources of saturated fat were cheese, pizza, ice cream, and eggs. Leading sources of added sugar were soft drinks, tea, fruit drinks, and cakes and pies. Based on the USDA “What We Eat in America” food list, other categories contributing to saturated fat intake include cold cuts, cream substitutes, fried potatoes, and whole milk. Categories with added sugar include tomato-based condiments, cereal bars, energy drinks, and yeast breads.
The research team also examined differences in the top sources of saturated fat and added sugar in a range of race/ethnicity subpopulations and age groups, an important detail when assessing diets to develop more personalized health interventions, Schembre said.
“Before you understand what you can intervene on, you have to know what people are consuming,” she said.
The team is creating an app for targeted assessment of “nutrients of concern,” and demonstrated that this analytic method produced a representative list of foods behind most saturated fat and added sugar intake. NHANES data is key to understanding nutrition in the United States, but for disease interventions, getting at the problem food and drink sources of fat, added sugar, and, still to come, sodium, is more efficient and effective.
Unsurprisingly, the results of this analysis showed that overall, saturated fat constituted at least 12% of a day’s calories, and added sugar consumption ranged from 14% to 16% of calories. Generally, dietary recommendations focus on avoiding the major contributors, like pizza and ice cream – which is what makes this longer list valuable and, for some, eye-opening, Taylor said.
“There are the foods that are higher in saturated fat and added sugar that are consumed frequently, and they get targeted, but there’s also that smaller cumulative effect of things that are generally perceived as healthy, but they’re all contributing just a little bit,” he said. “And then when you top it off with some of those higher sources, it ends up taking you over the threshold for that 10% of the day’s calories.
“We’re trying to hit the sweet spot of capturing the big front-seat items, but also understanding those things that are stealthy contributors.”
This research was supported by the National Cancer Institute. Additional co-authors were Peter Madril of Ohio State; Cynthia Thompson, Kelli Richardson, and Edward Bedrick of the University of Arizona; Genevieve Dunton of the University of Southern California; Michelle Jospe of Georgetown Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center; and Rick Weiss of Viocare Inc.